2010 – Sony PlayStation 3: Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption on PS3 is the Wild West epic that had everyone saying "just one more mission" until 3 AM. This copy shows some surface wear from actual play time but works perfectly, ready to drop you back into John Marston's quest for redemption. Before Red Dead 2 made everyone cry about horses, this was the one that proved Rockstar could do more than car chases. A certified classic from when open-world games still felt like discovering something new.